Optimist vs. Pessimist Maps

Thumbnail

Years ago, my friend Chris Lysy made this cartoon about optimist and pessimist charts:

Last week, I applied the optimist vs. pessimist style to a map during Office Hours.

(The real version of the map was about a different topic in a different state, but you get the idea.)

The Traditional Map

I’ve written about traditional and storytelling approaches before. You’re probably familiar with this terminology already?

The traditional version would have a topical title and regular ol’ brand colors.

The Storytelling Map: Optimist Version

In this optimist version, we’ve got a:

  • “good” takeaway title;
  • “good” brand color;
  • “good” icon; and a
  • call-out box highlighting a superstar.

The Storytelling Map: Pessimist Version

In this pessimist version, we’ve got a:

  • “bad” takeaway title;
  • “bad” brand color;
  • “bad” icon; and a
  • call-out box highlighting a laggard.

Which Version Should You Use?

That obviously depends on your audience and context.

You’re welcome to reply with your own insights. I read every response.

Download These Maps

Want the Excel file that I used to create these maps? Reply "MAPS" and I'll send it to you.

More Resources about Maps

I doubt you need to make these exact county-level maps of Florida. But you probably need to make some other type of map. Here are some blog posts and YouTube videos to get you started.

How to Make a County-Level Map in Excel

Here's a 10-min video for you.

Small Multiples Maps

If your visualization feels too dense, you should give small multiples a try. This solution applies to maps, too.

Dynamic Maps

You can't directly add maps to interactive dashboards in Excel -- but you can use this workaround.

Gorgeous DataViz

Workshop Opportunities

I'm available for in-person workshops:

  • Friday, May 22: London
  • Tuesday, June 9: Boise
  • Monday, July 6: Oahu

Or, any other time. But I'll be traveling to these cities anyway, so you won't have to pay for travel costs for your training session.

DataViz News & Upcoming Events


Meet Ann K. Emery

A trusted data visualization leader for more than 10 years. On-site workshops for 25,000 researchers, evaluators, and scientists in 31 states and 11 countries. Online courses for 10,000 participants. 200 consulting clients. 5 kids. My first HYROX in Miami is this weekend! Yikes!!

Based in Orlando, travel everywhere for dataviz.

Newsletter company's address: 600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246

Unsubscribe · Preferences

The latest newsletters

Dataviz time-savers in everyday software, like Excel.